
Mulla (Hodja) Nasruddin & Vegetable Garden
One day Hodja entered a vegetable garden while its owner was absent and began to stuff a sack with fruits and vegetables. As he was about to leave, with the sack over his shoulder, the owner returned. “What are you doing here?” he asked suspiciously. Hodja answered without hesitation. “That wind storm we had this morning blew me here.” “I’ll accept that,” said the owner somewhat grudgingly. “But who picked those vegetables in your sack?” Again Hodja answered immediately. “The wind was very strong and was about to blow me away again, so I grabbed onto the first thing I could, which happened to be these vegetables I am still holding.” “I’ll accept that, too,” said the owner. “But how did the vegetables get into the sack?” “Funny you should mention that,” answered Hodja. “I’ve been wondering about it ever since I first saw you.”
Nareddin Hodja is like a national heritage for Turkish People.
We grew up with his stories.
He is called ‘Mulla Nasruddin’ in other muslim countries.
Idris Shah was one of those who had published an English book for him.
Some mystics like Osho, symbolizes him as the smiling Budha figure in Budhism.
First document I put in this website(www.muhammedinur.com/En) was related to him.
http://www.muhammedinur.com/En/islam/questioning-the-design-in-creation.html
I had never heard this one before but a friend of mine put this one in the morning and I found it magnificent and I wanted to elevate it to our website so that our brothers and sisters may also benefit from this .
You know from the hadiths of Rasulullah SAWS that the guard watching JaHaNNam is called MALIQ(The Owner) !…
Some of authentic Nasreddin Hodja’s sayings will be related to the Batini (Inner/Unmanifested) Meanings which are hidden in his sayings.
Many people laugh at these sayings but would not understand what these are really stating. What is the sack there?
What is the wind?
What is the vegetable garden?
Who is the Owner ?
Why is he questioning him?
What is the meaning of all of these?
There are so many questions to ask when you read a narration related to Nasreddin Hodja. As a poor servant of Allah , I will try to comment on this by writing what I feel about this inshaallah. So please forgive me if I make any errors. All errors are related to my ego and all beautiful things you see come from ALLAH j.j and His Rasul (saws).
Meaning one: This world is like a Jahannam(Hell) for the Believer, He is thrown in to this world by the will of God (Qadha & Qadar, Wind) and if he puts anything in to his heart (sack) from the desires(fruits and vegetables) of this world other than what is permissible to him by laws of God, the watchguard Maliq will not let him have it and will chase after him. That is the reason when you die, you go in to grave naked with only your shroud by leaving everything behind. You can not take anything with you to the otherside but your deeds…
Humanbeing may remain in the harsh circumstances and in difficulties where he may resort to some of impermissible things which is mentioned as the storm and him trying to hold on to something in this wind. For instance, in Islam eating porke is allowed in some difficult conditions.
Meaning two:
When the person does not know that His Lord ( Al-Maliq: The name of ALLAH meaning the ONE who owns everything) is the Owner of everything, He is the ONE who granted him his body, mind, heart, soul and everything freely, but he will attempt to claim ownership to himself and forget his Lord is like someone stealing something from The Owner of everything. Using, eating, drinking all the sustenence provided to him by the Name of His Lord (Bismillahirrahmanirrahiym) is free but using them for his nafsanic desires by passing the boundaries set by ALLAH is like stealing…
Meaning Three:
Hodja is the True believer thinking that everything belongs to God and given to the common use of public by God. He comes there with this thought and his act of picking things when he is in difficulty is also not a stealing, but when someone is questioning him and claiming ownership to what God gave to common use, he got confused by this because a crime has appeared and he is puzzled. The last sentence he uses to respond him is like satirizing the condition. He is satirizing the people claiming ownership to the world, knowledge, etc.
There are more works here but I wanted to leave them to you readers and I hope some brothers and sisters will see more things than we did in this narration.
Guard of the Heaven is called RIDVAN in Islam. There is RIDHA (consent and pleasure ) of GOD is hidden within the word RIDVAN. Those names are from the hadiths inshaallah.
Allah knows best.
As SaLaM and Love
GaribAN

In facebook a brother told me that Life is a blessing and I can not consider the life an earth to be like Hell. I am attaching my response to him as below because this bit relates to the expression written above for Meaning one:
In Meaning one above, there is something hidden there on first sentence mentioning Hell. It gives you wrong impression. These sentences from my teacher Kulihvani and ayat and hadiths will shed light on the essence of my sayings inshaallah. If we ponder over them, this will take us somewhere inshaallah :
“We cook the food of the heaven in the fire of Hell.” [Kulihvani]
“Heaven and Hell are the same place, the diffrence is the existence or nonexistence of the NUR(divine light).” [Kulihvani]
“Most beautiful roses grow in the manure/compost but manure is not eaten.” [Kulihvani]
” When a man was asking Rasulullah SAWS ‘ you made every where heaven and left no space for hell. Where did the hell go? ‘ Rasulullah SAWS said Fa Subhanallah , I am telling you that the sun has risen and you are asking where did the night go?”[Kulihvani]
“There is no ILLA ALLAH without LA ILAHA, Both parts are necessary and to be said together to make TAWHEED!…” [Kulihvani]
LA ILAHA: There is no GOD : Denial of GOD
ILLA ALLAH: Only ALLAH exist(but ALLAH): Affirmation of GOD.
LA ILAHA ILLA ALLAH: There is no God but ALLAH (Unity!)
DUAL SYSTEM:
LA ILAHA —-ILLA ALLAH
HELL —- HEAVEN
NIGHT —– DAY
EVIL —— GOOD
DENIAL —-AFFIRMATION
“JaNNat is the balanced optimum point between maximum and minimum. 36 C degree is a balanced temperature for the human body and it is like JaNNat for the body. If it becomes over 40 C it becomes Hot JaHaNNam which is called Jahiym in the Qur’AN. If it goes below certain temperature it becomes like cold JaHaNNaM which is called Zamhari in the Qur’AN…”[Kulihvani]
“The Sun is a necessity for us from a distance but you don’t embrace it, because it is a fire source!”[GaribAN]
“Not one of you but will Pass over it(JaHaNNaM): this is, with thy Lord, a decree which must be accomplished” [ Qur’an 19/71 ]
“World is a dungeon for the believer(Mumin) and Paradise for the disbeliever(Kafir)” [ Hadith – Muslim]
“World is the field of the akhira” [Daylami]
Dear brother Jannah and Jahannam are not places which are going to be established after death only. In hanafi mazhab itikad, they both exist right at this moment (EL-AN).
“Akhirat Life is not something behind the doors of death. They are the truths being lived right at the moment ” says Dr.Munir Derman(k.s).
We need to find Jannah in this life here while we are in this body. Humanity still could not figure out what is Jannah , what is Jahannam as many people are thinking in dual system. Duality of Jannah and Jahannam should disappear. When you pass the boundaries of the earth sun is always shining. Duality is within the world my dear friend. Because it keeps spinning!… It is day and night one after the other because it is spinning, but in the space it is always day light…You pass through 7 layers of atmosphere to get there, read that previous sentence again, it is important to understand this !.For a true believer , his journey in the world is a suffering like Hell but there is good in this suffering as it is bringing enlightenment to him. Hell is the Heaven and blessing for him, if he can turn it in to heaven for himself !…There are no two places my friend! Satan is even a blessing for the believer although he is his enemy!…
We put a barrier infront of the river to make the river stronger. Satan is a barrier like this for human being in this life. If you listen to Satan , you get in to trouble but if you don’t listen to him, it gives benefit to us.
Test of servanthood would not be here for us, if there were no duality and satan. As humanity, we still could not figure out what Satan is either…
Every thing is a NiMaT for the true believer, even Jahannam and Satan, if used well inshaallah…
Look Rasulullah SAWS says in a hadith: ” I made my Satan muslim and he orders me good…” Watch out, he does not say, I killed my satan!..We need to think of these sayings carefully, things may look contrary to each other but they are not if we live Tawheed, if we analyse them carefully inshaallah.
Allah knows best
As SaLaM and Love
GaribAN